FOR THE RECORD · QUESTION NO. 01 · GIG WORKERS & THE LABOR DIVIDE
Should gig workers be classified as employees, remain independent contractors, or does the law require a new intermediate category?
The rise of app-based platforms has transformed how millions of people work, blurring the traditional legal line between staff and independent freelancers. As jurisdictions worldwide struggle to balance worker protections with corporate flexibility, the stakes for the future of the labor market have never been higher.
Click to expand a background reading
Individuals who provide rides or deliveries through app-based platforms are generally classified as independent contractors rather than employees; this is a key distinction and carries significant legal weight. Employees are entitled to numerous benefits like minimum wage, overtime compensation, unemployment insurance, and workers’ compensation for workplace injuries, and their employers contribute a share of Social Security and Medicare taxes, whereas Independent contractors ordinarily receive none of these protections and bear their own business expenses, including fuel, insurance, and vehicle maintenance.
The law distinguishes between the two categories primarily by examining control and independence. Traditional tests consider whether a company directs how, when, and where work is performed, and whether the worker operates an entirely independent business. One can see how the gig economy complicates this analysis and muddies the waters between this distinction. Gig workers (in the delivery/driving sectors) have significant independence and control as they determine their own schedules and may work for competing platforms simultaneously, yet the companies set prices, assign tasks, and may deactivate workers whose ratings fall below certain thresholds.
To protect workers, several jurisdictions have taken action, with California having adopted a particularly stringent approach. In Dynamex Operations West, Inc. v. Superior Court (2018), the California Supreme Court adopted the “ABC test,” which presumes that a worker is an employee unless the hiring entity establishes three conditions, including that the work falls outside the usual course of its business. This standard is difficult for rideshare companies to satisfy, given that transportation is central to their operations. The legislature codified the test in 2019 through Assembly Bill 5. In response, app-based companies supported Proposition 22, a 2020 ballot measure that preserved contractor status for their drivers while guaranteeing certain benefits, including minimum earnings of 120 percent of the minimum wage for time spent completing assignments, a health care stipend for drivers meeting hourly thresholds, and occupational accident insurance. Voters approved the measure, and the California Supreme Court upheld it in 2024. Critics note, however, that the earnings guarantee applies only to “engaged time” and excludes periods spent awaiting assignments.
Other jurisdictions have pursued alternative approaches. In 2024, Uber and Lyft reached a settlement with the Massachusetts Attorney General establishing a minimum pay rate for drivers while maintaining their contractor classification, demonstrating small steps being taken to protect gig workers. In 2021, the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom held that Uber drivers qualify as “workers,” an intermediate category that affords some, but not all, employee protections. The European Union adopted a directive in 2024 establishing a rebuttable presumption that platform workers are employees. In the United States, the Department of Labour’s position on worker classification has shifted across presidential administrations.
Proponents of contractor status maintain that flexibility is essential to the model. Many gig workers value the ability to work on their own schedules, often alongside education or other employment, and mandatory employee classification could result in fixed shifts, reduced work opportunities, and higher consumer prices. Proponents of employee status contend that platforms benefit from the substantial control they exercise while transferring costs and risks to workers, many of whom rely on this income as their primary source of support.
WHERE RESPONSES STAND
ADD YOUR RESPONSE
Pick a position and briefly explain your reasoning. You don’t need a legal background—a clear argument is what counts.
HOUSE RULES
- Answer the question on the page
- Argue with positions, not people
- No names or identifying details—yours or anyone else’s
- No spam, links or promotion
- BLR editors review every response before it’s published
WANT TO KEEP GOING?
No responses yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!


Leave a Reply